Gaithersburg: 301-670-7030
Baltimore: 410-769-5400
Frederick: 301-668-2100
Contact Us For Legal Help

Railroad Injury Blog

How to Prove an FRSA Whistleblower Violation without a Smoking Gun

Friday, December 14, 2018

You have been suspended from work or terminated, and you know it’s because you reported that injury, or because you put in one too many safety reports and trainmasters were targeting you. But how do you prove it when there’s no smoking gun – no statement from management that you’re being fired for reporting your injury or safety complaint? Courts recognize that smoking gun evidence, conclusive evidence of wrongdoing, is typically unavailable cause employers are rarely so cooperative as to include a notation in your file that your discipline is for a reason expressly forbidden by law. Obviously, it is very infrequent that a railroad admits not just to possessing an impermissible motive, but also to acting on it. So proving you were terminated for making an injury or safety report is done most often through circumstantial evidence.

Circumstantial evidence is not only sufficient, but may even be more certain, or more persuasive. Circumstantial evidence that your protected activity, such as reporting injuries or safety complaints, contributed to your discipline may include several factors. First is temporal proximity. If the railroad charges you with rules violations shortly after you report your injury, that indicates the reason for the discipline was the injury report. Second are indications of pretext. When the railroad is vague about what you did to violate the rules, or its witnesses give contradicting statements about what occurred, that shows the reason for the discipline is not what the railroad is claiming. Third is an inconsistent application of the railroad’s policies. If the hammer is coming down hard on you, and a co-worker who committed the same violation a year ago but never reported a safety violation got off easy, that indicates the reason for your discipline was your safety report. Fourth is a railroad’s shifting explanations for its actions. When the railroad first charges you with one violation and then changes its mind to charge you with something else, that indicates that neither of the reasons the railroad gave is the real reason for the discipline.

Fifth is antagonism or hostility toward your protected activity. If your trainmaster tells you, “Don’t bring that BS to me,” when you make a safety complaint, or tells you that you should say your injury happened at home, it shows that any discipline you receive is related to what management was really upset about – your protected activity. Sixth is the falsity of the railroad’s explanation for the discipline. If you can prove there is no way you committed the rule violation you are charged with, and the railroad knew it, then it’s clear the railroad was really motivated by your record of safety complaints. Finally, are changes in the railroad’s attitude towards you after you engaged in protected activity. When you make an injury report, and the trainmaster who you used to be friendly with now won’t look you in the eye because you messed up his numbers for the year, it tends to show that the discipline you received was for reporting that injury.

Proving you were discriminated against because of your protected activity under the FRSA is obviously a tricky business. That is why you need experienced FRSA attorneys with knowledge of railroads and their practices to represent you when you are suspended or terminated from work, and you know it was for an unlawful reason.

Recent Posts


Tags


Archive

RSS

What Our Clients Say

Known for our unwavering commitment to clients, for our integrity, and for delivering the best results, our clients continue to refer their friends, families and neighbors to us for their legal needs.


"One year ago today I made the call to your office. The best decision I could make. I wanted to share with you how impressed I am with your staff and your professionalism."

Heather P.


"Craig did a great job representing me! He's the lawyer I have trusted with my legal needs because he's professional, knowledgeable, and keeps me informed about my case."

Jaclyn K.


"I would like to express my gratitude for your efforts and dedication for my disability case. It's has been quite a long and upsetting process but you have handled my case in an extremely competent and responsible manner."

Leo H.


"I have recommended Mr. Feldman to several of my friends and colleagues and have heard nothing but excellent reviews. He is the best lawyer I have ever used."

Martin


"I received the check today. I could not believe it until I saw the check. Thank you so much. You have improved my family's quality of life tenfold."

Mike F.


"These guys go above and beyond! They always have your best interest in mind."

Mike W.


"You have been kind throughout this process and I appreciate your professionalism as well as your gentle concern. Thanks for helping us and all the others who need your legal expertise. We are grateful."

Nancy F.


"Thanks to Mr. Shultz's aggressive and professional work ethic style I was able to receive the medical services and compensation pertaining to my case."

Navdeep C.


"I can honestly say this firm is simply TOP NOTCH! They not only have handled countless cases for my members that require their services, they also have gone well beyond their "scope" to help some of my folks in other areas of need. "

Rick H.


"The attention and professional care the staff has taken toward my needs has always been excellent. I have no complaints nor worries that my issues discussed are not addressed."

Tim T.


"I just got off the phone with Craig and let him know how thankful we are to you, him and Ken for all your efforts – you are all really terrific to work with!"

Val K.


Locations Throughout Maryland, Virginia & Washington DC

Gaithersburg Office

481 N. Frederick Avenue, Suite 300
Gaithersburg, MD 20877
301-670-7030 / 800-248-3352
Fax: 301-670-9492

Lutherville Office

1301 York Road, Suite 600
Lutherville, MD 21093
410-769-5400 / 800-248-3352
Fax: 410-769-9200

Frederick Office

30 W. Patrick Street, Suite 105
Frederick, MD 21701
301-668-2100 / 800-827-2667
Fax: 301-668-2000

Subscribe To Our Newsletter


TOP